When I went to that Cheese competition a few months ago, the best in show was a Beecher cheddar. That new cheese book that I bought has a recipe in it for Just Jack, which the cheese maker at Beecher cheese gave the recipe to the author in a 1 gallon batch. I am going to make it tomorrow, in a 4 gallon batch. I am going to make a 2lb pepper jack and a 2lb Just Jack from it. I make a good pepper jack, but it needs to be a little moister and creamier. (It’s all about improvement until it’s perfect, in your opinion.)
This one calls for a cup of heavy whipping cream per gallon of milk. That should help with the creamy part. It also has the curds cut a little larger, and it presses at lighter pressure. I am excited to try it.
I bought a piece of Beecher Marco Polo at the grocery store while ago. http://store.beechershandmadecheese.com/p-35-marco-polo-1-lb.aspx
They only had two Beecher’s and the other one is called “No Woman”. I tried that at the cheese competition and I didn’t like it. It has Jamaican jerk spice in it.
The Marco Polo has green and black pepper corns.