Mike,
First of all, congratulations on your initial success. I agree that there is nothing that feels quite as good (at least at my age) as a nice clean break.
This is an extremely easy hobby to get hooked on.
I’ve been making cheese for three years now and, if anything, the thrill is stronger now than it’s ever been.
I’m also interested in the size of wheel you are making and the amount of weight you are using to press your cheese.
In my personal experience I’ve found that as you go up in wheel size (6”, 7-1/2”, 8” diameter) the pressing weight has to increase to get the curds to knit together well.
Of course there are also many other variables such as cooking temperature and PH, but I’ve honestly never had a problem with those parts of the process.
Since I’ve increased my pressing weights I’ve never had a single problem with getting my curd to knit together and I think that others (Green Cheese Maker, especially) will agree.
If you will do a quick search you will find numerous posts concerning this subject. It all has to do with pounds per square inch that you are exerting on your wheel.
Btw…..
This is not my discovery. I was coaxed by other home cheese makers to give this method a try and I have to say that I’ve had nothing but great results from following their advice.
Even if this particular curd does not knit together as well as you might like, don’t toss it.
Simply put it in your cave and give it a try in a month or so. You might be pleasantly surprised at the taste, even if the texture isn’t exactly what you had in mind.
Dave